D4RPoMM - Recent changes [en]

User:JuanSobreira

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:28:01 GMT

User account JuanSobreira was created by AnnaRodeghiero

PoMM for the Santander D4Runoff pilot

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:10:16 GMT

FCM Santander case

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:10, 15 April 2026
Line 3:		Line 3:

	=== [[FCM Santander case]] ===		=== [[FCM Santander case]] ===
	~~For this case see the Report on PoMM Implementation in Santander.~~
	=== [[The ABM simulation tests & results]] in D4Runoff pilot cases ===		=== [[The ABM simulation tests & results]] in D4Runoff pilot cases ===
	Back to Back to >> [[Using the PoMM at the D4Runoff pilot sites]]		Back to Back to >> [[Using the PoMM at the D4Runoff pilot sites]]
	Back to >> [[Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation#Case Studies and Applications\| Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation]]		Back to >> [[Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation#Case Studies and Applications\| Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation]]

FCM Santander case

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:09:38 GMT

Cognitive Map Information

Show changes

File:InterventionImpact.png

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 15:52:04 GMT

AnnaRodeghiero uploaded File:InterventionImpact.png

New page

InterventionImpact

File:InterventionPlot.png

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 15:48:47 GMT

AnnaRodeghiero uploaded File:InterventionPlot.png

New page

InterventionPlot

FCM Santander case

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 15:47:53 GMT

Comparison Table

Show changes

File:SantanderTabellaIntervento.png

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 15:27:03 GMT

AnnaRodeghiero uploaded File:SantanderTabellaIntervento.png

New page

SantanderTabellaIntervento

FCM Santander case

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 15:08:00 GMT

Cognitive map design

File:Santander-FCMConcepts.png

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:58:38 GMT

AnnaRodeghiero uploaded File:Santander-FCMConcepts.png

New page

Santander-FCMConcepts

FCM Santander case

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:56:30 GMT

Cognitive map design

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:56, 15 April 2026
(8 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 12:		Line 12:

	<blockquote>		<blockquote>
	What intervention in the current policy-making and decision-making process would encourage and facilitate the development of a minimalist (“do the minimum” / current conditions) emerging pollutants management plan for urban runoff that includes NBS, inspired by compliance with the EU Directive on urban wastewater treatment, and plausible given the current state of affairs?		'''''What intervention in the current policy-making and decision-making process would encourage and facilitate the development of a minimalist (“do the minimum” / current conditions) emerging pollutants management plan for urban runoff that includes NBS, inspired by compliance with the EU Directive on urban wastewater treatment, and plausible given the current state of affairs?'''''
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Line 49:		Line 49:

	The process examined is described according to the '''BPMN standard'''.		The process examined is described according to the '''BPMN standard'''.
			[[File:SantanderCase-BPMN.png\|alt=Santander BPMN case\|left\|thumb\|Santander BPMN case]]



	In the Santander context, compliance with the new UWWTD requires the design of a provisional and experimental regulatory hypothesis for developing approximation policies. Therefore, the decision process flow outlined is itself an intervention design.		In the Santander context, compliance with the new UWWTD requires the design of a provisional and experimental regulatory hypothesis for developing approximation policies. Therefore, the decision process flow outlined is itself an intervention design.

	Due to its project nature, the current initial values of the variables were not available and were therefore assigned a minimum value (different from zero for technical reasons).		Due to its project nature, the current initial values of the variables were not available and were therefore assigned a minimum value (different from zero for technical reasons).
			<p>
	The process is structured in '''three phases''':		The process is structured in '''three phases''':

Line 59:		Line 62:
	# Technical-political project		# Technical-political project
	# Experimentation and evaluation		# Experimentation and evaluation


	The '''Ayuntamiento de Santander (Concejalía de Medio Ambiente)''' takes the political and technical lead and drives the process through the following steps:		The '''Ayuntamiento de Santander (Concejalía de Medio Ambiente)''' takes the political and technical lead and drives the process through the following steps:
Line 89:		Line 93:
	The following variables were selected for the experiment:		The following variables were selected for the experiment:

	* Competencia de los expertos (Amplitud y especialización de los conocimientos)		# Competencia de los expertos (Amplitud y especialización de los conocimientos)
	* Numero y impacto de proyectos con participación directa de la ciudadanía		# Numero y impacto de proyectos con participación directa de la ciudadanía
	* Indicaciones para el ajuste UWWTD		# Indicaciones para el ajuste UWWTD
	* Impacto CapEx OpEx Gestor SII		# Impacto CapEx OpEx Gestor SII
	* Impacto positivo sobre la calidad del agua		# Impacto positivo sobre la calidad del agua
	* Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion		# Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion
	* Eficacia del proceso de concesión de permisos para SbN		# Eficacia del proceso de concesión de permisos para SbN
	* Impacto de los proyectos apruebados		# Impacto de los proyectos apruebados
	* Impacto CapEx OpEx Otros Servicios		# Impacto CapEx OpEx Otros Servicios
	* Indices de multifuncionalidad SbN inundaciones, sequías, CEs		# Indices de multifuncionalidad SbN inundaciones, sequías, CEs
	* Impacto operativo sobre Otros servicios		# Impacto operativo sobre Otros servicios
	* Nivel de cumplimiento del plan de gestión propuesto con la normativa vigente y futura		# Nivel de cumplimiento del plan de gestión propuesto con la normativa vigente y futura
	* Beneficios-costos para el municipio		# Beneficios-costos para el municipio
	* Importancia del tema escorrentía urbana CEs-SbN y UWWTD en la agenda política		# Importancia del tema escorrentía urbana CEs-SbN y UWWTD en la agenda política
	* Incremento de capacidad del sistema		# Incremento de capacidad del sistema
	* Impacto positivo en la calidad del agua vertida		# Impacto positivo en la calidad del agua vertida
	* Calidad de la colaboracion interistitucional		# Calidad de la colaboracion interistitucional
	* Cumplimiento con las políticas regionales y nacionales de MEDIO AMBIENTE y SALUD		# Cumplimiento con las políticas regionales y nacionales de MEDIO AMBIENTE y SALUD
	* Beneficios-costes total Gestor SII		# Beneficios-costes total Gestor SII
	* Nivel de correspondencia de las SbN con los mapas de zonas de riesgo		# Nivel de correspondencia de las SbN con los mapas de zonas de riesgo
	* Numero y impacto de inversiones SbN particulares autorizadas		# Numero y impacto de inversiones SbN particulares autorizadas
	* Calidad del monitoreo CEs		# Calidad del monitoreo CEs
	* Impacto positivo sobre la capacidad de carga EDAR		# Impacto positivo sobre la capacidad de carga EDAR
	* Indice de correspondencia de las SbN con los mapas de riesgo		# Indice de correspondencia de las SbN con los mapas de riesgo
	* Nivel de consenso político		# Nivel de consenso político
	* Impacto positivo sobre CSO		# Impacto positivo sobre CSO
	* Beneficios-costes total Otros Servicios		# Beneficios-costes total Otros Servicios
	* Concienciación, compromiso y apoyo de los ciudadanos y las organizaciones de la sociedad civil		# Concienciación, compromiso y apoyo de los ciudadanos y las organizaciones de la sociedad civil
	* Impacto CapEx OpEx EDAR Depuracion		# Impacto CapEx OpEx EDAR Depuracion

	== Cognitive Map Information ==		== Cognitive Map Information ==
Line 215:		Line 219:

	This image represents the cognitive map designed for the experiment.		This image represents the cognitive map designed for the experiment.

	~~[[File:Cognitive_map_Santander.png\|center\|800px\|Cognitive Map Design]]~~

	== Relationships between entities ==		== Relationships between entities ==

File:SantanderCase-BPMN.png

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:48:23 GMT

AnnaRodeghiero uploaded File:SantanderCase-BPMN.png

New page

SantanderCase-BPMN

FCM Santander case

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:45:59 GMT

Implementation of the PoMM Module in the Pilot Sites – Santander (ES)

Show changes

PoMM for the Santander D4Runoff pilot

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 13:59:17 GMT

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:59, 15 April 2026
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1:		Line 1:

			Key policymakers from the Municipality of Santander and the utility company that manages the water service were involved in testing the PoMM module for the Santander pilot site.

			=== [[FCM Santander case]] ===
	For this case see the Report on PoMM Implementation in Santander.		For this case see the Report on PoMM Implementation in Santander.
			=== [[The ABM simulation tests & results]] in D4Runoff pilot cases ===
	Back to >> [[~~SEN:~~Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation\|Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation]]		Back to Back to >> [[Using the PoMM at the D4Runoff pilot sites]]
			Back to >> [[Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation#Case Studies and Applications\| Comprehensive Knowledge Base and Full Documentation]]

User:JesusFernandez

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 13:49:13 GMT

User account JesusFernandez was created by AnnaRodeghiero

User:JesusFerndandez

AnnaRodeghiero — Wed, 15 Apr 2026 13:45:53 GMT

User account JesusFerndandez was created by AnnaRodeghiero

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:08, 15 April 2026
Line 219:		Line 219:

	This image represents the cognitive map designed for the experiment.		This image represents the cognitive map designed for the experiment.
			[[File:Santander-FCMConcepts.png\|center\|800x800px]]

	== Relationships between entities ==		== Relationships between entities ==
Line 387:		Line 388:

	{\| class="wikitable sortable"		{\| class="wikitable sortable"
	! Source Concept		! Source Concept (Cause)
	! Target Concept		! Target Concept (Effect)
	! Reasoning		! Reasoning (Why)
	\|-		\|-
	\| Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion		\| Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion (Total Cost Benefit: WWTP)
	\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio		\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio (Municipality Cost-Benefit)
	\| The economic efficiency of the WWTP directly contributes to the overall economic benefit of the municipality.		\| The economic efficiency of the WWTP directly contributes to the overall economic benefit of the municipality.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Beneficios-costes total Gestor SII		\| Beneficios-costes total Gestor SII (Total Cost-Benefit: Sewer Manager)
	\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio		\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio
	\| The efficiency of the sewer infrastructure manager contributes strongly to the municipality's economic balance.		\| The efficiency of the sewer infrastructure manager contributes strongly to the municipality's economic balance.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio		\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio (Municipality Cost-Benefit)
	\| Indicaciones para el ajuste UWWTD		\| Indicaciones para el ajuste UWWTD (Indications for UWWTD Adjustment)
	\| A positive economic balance is a prerequisite for defining valid adjustments to comply with the directive.		\| A positive economic balance is a prerequisite for defining valid adjustments to comply with the directive.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Calidad de la colaboracion interistitucional		\| Calidad de la colaboracion interistitucional (Quality of Inter-institutional Collab)
	\| Cumplimiento con las políticas regionales y nacionales de MEDIO AMBIENTE y SALUD		\| Cumplimiento con las políticas regionales y nacionales de MEDIO AMBIENTE y SALUD (Env. Policy Compliance)
	\| Strong cooperation between institutions helps ensure compliance with environmental and health policies.		\| Strong cooperation between institutions helps ensure compliance with environmental and health policies.
	\|-		\|-
Line 411:		Line 412:
	\| High-quality collaboration is essential to agree on how to implement UWWTD adjustments.		\| High-quality collaboration is essential to agree on how to implement UWWTD adjustments.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Calidad del monitoreo CEs		\| Calidad del monitoreo CEs (Quality of Monitoring Emerging Contaminants)
	\| Impacto positivo en la calidad del agua vertida		\| Impacto positivo en la calidad del agua vertida Positive Impact: Discharged Water)
	\| Better monitoring allows better treatment management, improving effluent quality.		\| Better monitoring allows better treatment management, improving effluent quality.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Calidad del monitoreo CEs		\| Calidad del monitoreo CEs
	\| Impacto positivo sobre la calidad del agua		\| Impacto positivo sobre la calidad del agua (Positive Impact: Water Quality)
	\| General water quality improves when monitoring systems are robust.		\| General water quality improves when monitoring systems are robust.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Competencia de los expertos		\| Competencia de los expertos (Expert Competence)
	\| Nivel de correspondencia de las SbN con los mapas de zonas de riesgo		\| Nivel de correspondencia de las SbN con los mapas de zonas de riesgo (SbN alignment with Risk Maps)
	\| Knowledgeable experts ensure that NBS are located correctly according to risk zones.		\| Knowledgeable experts ensure that NBS are located correctly according to risk zones.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Concienciación ciudadana		\| Concienciación... ciudadana (Citizen Awareness/Support)
	\| Nivel de consenso político		\| Nivel de consenso político (Political Consensus)
	\| Public support helps build political consensus.		\| Public support helps build political consensus.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Cumplimiento con las políticas		\| Cumplimiento con las políticas ...(Policy Compliance)
	\| Nivel de cumplimiento del plan de gestión		\| Nivel de cumplimiento del plan de gestión (Management Plan Compliance)
	\| Adhering to high-level policies ensures that the management plan aligns with present and future regulations.		\| Adhering to high-level policies ensures that the management plan aligns with present and future regulations.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Eficacia del proceso de permisos SbN		\| Eficacia del proceso de permisos SbN (NBS Permitting Efficacy)
	\| Numero y impacto de inversiones SbN		\| Numero y impacto de inversiones SbN (No. & Impact of SbN Investments)
	\| Efficient permits help unlock private investments in NBS.		\| Efficient permits help unlock private investments in NBS.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Impacto CapEx OpEx EDAR Depuracion		\| Impacto CapEx OpEx EDAR Depuracion (WWTP Operational/Capital Expenses)
	\| Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion		\| Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion (Total Cost-Benefit: WWTP)
	\| Managing operational and capital costs is the main driver of WWTP cost-benefit performance.		\| Managing operational and capital costs is the main driver of WWTP cost-benefit performance.
	\|-		\|-
Line 463:		Line 464:
	\| Cleaner discharged water helps the management plan meet regulatory targets.		\| Cleaner discharged water helps the management plan meet regulatory targets.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Impacto positivo sobre CSO		\| Impacto positivo sobre CSO (Positive Impact on Sewer Overflows)
	\| Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion		\| Beneficios-costes total EDAR Depuracion
	\| Reducing sewer overflows strongly improves WWTP cost-benefit.		\| Reducing sewer overflows strongly improves WWTP cost-benefit.
Line 495:		Line 496:
	\| Freeing up plant load directly increases system capacity.		\| Freeing up plant load directly increases system capacity.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Importancia del tema en la agenda política		\| Importancia del tema en la agenda política (Political Agenda Importance)
	\| Calidad de la colaboracion interistitucional		\| Calidad de la colaboracion interistitucional
	\| When the issue becomes a political priority, institutions are pushed to collaborate more effectively.		\| When the issue becomes a political priority, institutions are pushed to collaborate more effectively.
Line 503:		Line 504:
	\| Higher capacity yields better economic returns for the city.		\| Higher capacity yields better economic returns for the city.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Indices de multifuncionalidad SbN		\| Indices de multifuncionalidad SbN (SbN Multifunctionality Indices)
	\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio		\| Beneficios-costos para el municipio
	\| Multi-purpose green solutions create economic value.		\| Multi-purpose green solutions create economic value.
Line 515:		Line 516:
	\| Political agreement is a requirement for finalizing UWWTD guidelines.		\| Political agreement is a requirement for finalizing UWWTD guidelines.
	\|-		\|-
	\| Nivel de correspondencia SbN con mapas		\| Nivel de correspondencia SbN con mapas (Alignment with Risk Maps)
	\| Eficacia del proceso de concesión de permisos para SbN		\| Eficacia del proceso de concesión de permisos para SbN
	\| Projects aligned with risk maps are more easily permitted.		\| Projects aligned with risk maps are more easily permitted.